A paper—my paper—passes from the professor’s hand to that of a stu­dent, and then to another, and another, and so on until it comes back to me. Paper in hand, it’s now my turn to read as I first glance skep­ti­cally around the class­room. Some eyes are kind, expec­tant, encour­ag­ing. Others, most oth­ers, are fixed elsewhere—on shoes, on fin­gers fid­get­ing with car keys, on cell phones—just not on me.

I stand and start anyway.

A young man falls in love with an older woman, and they have a short but tor­rid love affair. She, how­ever, is car­ry­ing a lot of baggage—and he’s not a porter.”

I look up briefly to see whether the pun arrests approval. It doesn’t. I return to my page.

She picks up her bag­gage and leaves.

As might be expected where duty rivals devo­tion in a young man’s heart and purse, he writes a long and tor­rid novel about their short and tor­rid affair—by which he hopes to purge his pain and make lunch-money. He doesn’t. No one wants his novel. The love scenes result in many dates with rabidly curi­ous agents—all one-afternoon stands. The agents know the book won’t sell—that the writer and his novel are both lost causes. But he is, after all, cute.

One agent with a heart, how­ever, tells him after short sex to cut, cut, cut. Obligingly, he does. The long and tor­rid novel becomes shorter, much shorter, then shorter still. The man has found a new rhythm—and a new lust. His novel becomes a novella, then a short story. He sub­mits it to mag­a­zines and lit­er­ary jour­nals of weight, all of which reject it.

He resolves to fur­ther cut.

At last, he has a piece of micro-fiction resem­bling a haiku—right down to the Japanese-sounding syntax.

Boy meets girl by day;
they love much.
But come the night, they fin­ish such.

It rhymes and has one syl­la­ble too few for a true haiku. He insists it’s really only half a syl­la­ble, but peo­ple aren’t buying—his expla­na­tion or the rhyming haiku. He has it printed on the front and back of a T-shirt and walks the street like a bill­board, arms and legs (for a bill­board) an anatom­i­cal anom­aly. Passers-by rapidly scan the first two verses on the front of his T-shirt, but avert their eyes when he beseeches con­tact. Instead, heads look straight ahead—and only then turn to read the last verse once he’s passed them by.

He dies, slowly and mis­er­ably, of neglect—and is buried in a potter’s field next to other unloved, under­nour­ished and mis­un­der­stood poets.

The end.”

I sit down to silence. Stunned and awestruck, I expect (given the tec­tonic tilt of my emer­gence as the next new thing). And yet, I note there’s not a wet eye in the house. Pins—if they could now be dropped—would sound like thun­der. The pro­fes­sor clears his throat.

That’s your syn­op­sis?”

It is, sir.”

Uh-huh. And your hook?”

He has me on “hook,” but then I’m mer­ci­fully reminded that ‘those who can, do; those who can’t…’ “The hook, sir, is in the brevity. Pith, I feel—.”

You feel? Is this sup­posed hook of yours about feel­ing?” The mus­cles in his face could make a cir­cus of a snicker.

Pith,” I con­tinue notwith­stand­ing, “is the thing. It’s tragedy on a tight leash, a short string, sir.”

I see,” he says—but clearly doesn’t. His eyes and hands are already busy with his pile of oth­ers’ papers. I can see he’s get­ting set for the next read with­out fur­ther com­ment on mine, and that I’m going to miss my chance if I don’t act. It’s now or never.

Art is dying, sir. Pith in pulp is, are, the new watchword—uh, words.” He abruptly stops shuf­fling and looks at me over the tops of a pair of tortoise-shells, professorially-reclined. I take a quick breath and con­tinue. “We have to keep pace—or we, too, shall die. You and I. All of us here,” I con­clude with the sweep of one hand, now a lit­tle less con­fi­dent in my summation.

More pins could drop in the silence that ensues. Quislings, I think. MFA scum­bags. Sniveling snarklings. This is a club I want no part of.

Then you’d cater to con­for­mity, Mr. D.?” With that, he cuts me almost to the quick. And yet, I can now taste the blood of his lib­er­al­ity drip­ping from a com­fort­ably tenured tooth and claw.

No, sir. I’m a sur­vivor. I want to pro­duce. But I’d also occa­sion­ally like to consume.”

The atmos­phere grows tense. Authority fig­ures are a thing I’m still strug­gling with—as are we appar­ently all.

A smirk like heat light­ning begins to form upon his rum­pled lip. “Well, Mr. D., per­haps you’ll one day find your niche in the art of writ­ing annual reports. Big busi­ness pays quite well for that sort of thing, you know,” he says as he leans in over his small stack of papers and wags a fin­ger. “They like brevity, pith, and num­bers.” The last word pos­i­tively oozes from his lips as he lets a glance pass over his sur­round­ing pride of lit­tle cubs. He gets the gallows-nod he’s clearly seek­ing in hushed mur­murs and chuckles.

Fucking syco­phants, I think.

I real­ize it’s over, that I have noth­ing to lose. “Publish or per­ish, sir,” I say as I stuff my syn­op­sis into my knap­sack, stand again, then push in my chair. “Publish or perish.”

I walk to the door, open it, and step out. The room remains silent as a stone unturned. I know—perhaps oth­ers do, too—that noth­ing he’s writ­ten in over a decade has been pub­lished, that he’s washed up and over the hill. I sling my knap­sack up to my shoul­der and stick my head back in through the door for one part­ing punch.

Or per­ish,” I say, let­ting the last word sound like a death wish.